Close this search box.
8 Best Toddler Pillows in 2023

Who knew purchasing a pillow for your toddler would be such a big deal before becoming a mom? Scrolling through endless online reviews, searching Facebook group recommendations, feeling like you’ve been Googling for hours—only to feel more confused. 

We’ve taken the headache away. Our team of moms and experts put in the work for you so you can get back to snuggling your sweet toddler. Read on for a roundup of the 8 best toddler pillows in 2023. 

In a hurry? Here are the top picks:

  1. Best Overall Toddler Pillow
  2. Best Organic Toddler Pillow
  3. Best Cooling Toddler Pillow
  4. Best Breathable Toddler Pillow
  5. Best Comfortable Toddler Pillow
  6. Best Toddler Pillow for Support
  7. Best Hypoallergenic Toddler Pillow
  8. Best Affordable Toddler Pillow

Toddler Pillow vs. Regular Pillow: What’s the Difference? 

First-time moms often find it surprising that toddlers need their own special pillow. But why? The main differences between a toddler and a regular adult pillow are the size and fluffiness. Designed for toddlers, this type of pillow is used for transitioning from a strictly flat surface to adding some support under their little heads–it’s a huge adjustment. 

There is a risk of suffocation when toddlers use adult-sized pillows. Dr. Steven Alcuri, MD, a board-certified Pediatrician in Maryland with over 25 years of experience, suggests the average size of a toddler pillow should be around 12 by 16 inches in diameter, and 2 to 3 inches thick. You also don’t want something too plush. Support is the main goal with toddler pillows to help their growth while keeping them safe.

When Can a Toddler Have a Pillow?

Many pediatricians and sleep experts agree to wait until your little one is 2 years old to introduce a pillow. “Prior to that, pillows are not regarded as safe due to the risk of suffocation,” says Alcuri.

You should also hold off on using a pillow if your toddler is still sleeping in a crib. “Objects in a crib can be used as a climbing aid, creating a risk of falling over the rails,” explains Alcuri. Once your toddler hits 2 years of age and has transitioned into a toddler bed, then it’s considered safe to introduce a pillow.

Signs Your Toddler Needs a Pillow

So your toddler meets the requirements to introduce a pillow, but you’re not sure if they really need one yet. Doctor Alcuri lists a few signs to look out for that suggest your toddler is ready for their first pillow.

  • Restless sleep
  • Laying on blankets or soft toys as a pillow
  • Copying you and using your pillow
  • Frequent wake-ups

These signs are not the end-all-be-all. But giving your toddler a pillow to try could help improve their sleep and even make them feel excited and proud when it comes to getting some Zs.

1. Best Overall Toddler Pillow

KeaBabies Toddler Pillow

With over 32,000 ratings and a 4.7-star rating, it’s no wonder this was chosen as the best toddler pillow for sleeping. One mom even asked the brand “Do they sell an adult version of this pillow?” This is definitely a great option for your toddler’s first pillow. It’s safe, natural, gentle, breathable, provides support, is durable, and even comes in 29 different designs–what’s not to love?

Why we love it

  • Provides great spinal support
  • Made with breathable cotton
  • Easy to clean: washer & dryer friendly

Buy Now

2. Best Organic Toddler Pillow

The Avocado Organic Toddler Pillow

If non-toxic and organic material is important for your little one to rest their head on, this is your go-to toddler pillow. Winner of the 2021 Good Housekeeping Awards, climate neutral certified, and meeting the global organic textile standard, you can see why this is on our list as the best organic toddler pillow. Be sure to check out their organic waterproof pillow protector while you’re adding it to your cart!

Why we love it

  • Made from organic cotton
  • They automatically give you a 100-night trial
  • Handmade in the USA

Buy Now

3. Best Cooling Toddler Pillow

Continental Bedding Microfiber Toddler Cooling Pillow

Does your toddler run hot? If so, a microfiber pillow is a great option for cooling. This toddler pillow by Continental Bedding offers amazing temperature control that lasts all through the night. No more rolling from the right side of the pillow to the left looking for cool spots. They even ensure a comfortable and restful sleep with a money-back guarantee! 

Why we love it

  • Cooling temperature control
  • Free from odors and harmful chemicals
  • Machine washable and fast drying

Buy Now

4. Best Breathable Toddler Pillow

Woolino Toddler Wool Pillow

Did you know that wool is one of the most breathable fabrics? The Woolino toddler pillow is made from 100 percent Australian wool – pretty neat isn’t it, mate? They even deem it “superbly breathable.” The Woolino is also a great option for toddlers who are restless at night moving in different positions due to its cooling temperature regulation. Another plus? Fast shipping!

Why we love it

  • Super breathable 
  • Temperature regulating
  • Made from 100 percent natural Australian wool

Buy Now

5. Best Comfortable Toddler Pillow

Little One’s Toddler Pillow

Here’s a common misconception: pillows need to be super fluffy to be comfortable. Wrong—the key to a comfortable pillow is not solely based on softness, but the way it supports and hugs your head and neck instead. The Little One’s toddler pillow wins the comfortable award due to its coziness, warmth, support, and comfort. All of these benefits in one little pillow!

Why we love it

  • Soft 100 percent cotton shell
  • Designed with top chiropractors and pediatricians
  • Squishy fiber filling

Buy Now

6. Best Toddler Pillow for Support

Coop Sleep Goods Original Toddler Pillow

Having a supporting pillow for your toddler is important to their head, neck, and spine alignment at this critical growth stage in their life. The best part of this Coop Sleep Goods pillow is being able to adjust the thickness for personalized support. One dad even goes on to say these are “way better than many other pillows out there!” The Coop Sleep Goods pillow is a no-brainer as the best toddler pillow for support.

Why we love it

  • 100-day risk-free trial
  • Perfect mixture of soft & supportive
  • Adjustable fluffiness

Buy Now

7. Best Hypoallergenic Toddler Pillow

A Little Pillow Company Toddler Pillow

With a 100 percent cotton case and hypoallergenic polyester fibers from recycled BPA-free plastic bottles, this toddler pillow is revolutionary. One mom even goes on to say “Hands down, the best pillow on the market for kids!” If sensitivity is a big factor for your toddler, this is the pillow for them.

Why we love it

  • Made with hypoallergenic material 
  • Adjustable fill for support and height
  • Machine washable

Buy Now

8. Best Affordable Toddler Pillow

Babysland Toddler Pillow

A hotel-quality pillow for under $15? Can’t beat that! And don’t be fooled by the price, this pillow doesn’t slack on any features: High-thread-count cotton, ultra-smooth surface, and is still breathable & hypoallergenic. This one has to go down in the books for being the best affordable toddler pillow out there.

Why we love it

  • Half the price of other toddler pillows
  • Double stitched to prevent wear and tear
  • Machine washable and dry-able

Buy Now

How to Choose the Best Pillow for Your Toddler

Choosing a good pillow for your baby’s head requires in-depth consideration and attention to detail. The right pillow can make or break your little one’s sleep quality, comfort, and overall health. 

During your search, keep in mind pillow features such as material, size, firmness, and breathability. Always be sure to follow the recommended age guidelines and consult with a pediatrician if you have any questions about finding the right pillow. 

By taking the time to find the best pillow for your toddler, you can help ensure they get the quality sleep they need to grow and thrive – without wasting extra time and money going through all the wrong ones.

H2: 8 Best Toddler Pillows

PillowWhat We ThinkStar RatingPriceLink to Buy
KeaBabiesBest Overall4.7/5$39.96Buy Now
AvocadoBest Organic4.6/5$24Buy Now
Continental BeddingBest Cooling4.3/5$33.99Buy Now
WoolinoBest Breathable4.9/5$35.99Buy Now
Little One’s PillowBest for Comfort4.6/5$29.99Buy Now
Coop Sleep GoodsBest for Support4.9/5$35Buy Now
A Little Pillow CompanyBest Hypoallergenic4.8/5$30Buy Now
BabyslandBest Affordable4.7/5$14.99Buy Now

Contributing Experts:

Dr. Steven Alcuri, MD, is a board-certified Pediatrician in Maryland with over 25 years of experience. His specialty is giving individualized attention in an unhurried atmosphere to newborn babies up to adolescents.